Prop 65 for Food and Supplement Brands: What You Need to Know

If you sell food or dietary supplements in California, Proposition 65 decides whether your label needs a warning. The trigger isn’t simply whether a listed chemical is in your product. It’s how much of that chemical a consumer is exposed to per day.

Prop 65, formally the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, requires businesses to give a “clear and reasonable” warning before exposing people in California to chemicals known to cause cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm. The list holds hundreds of chemicals. For food and supplement brands, four heavy metals cause most of the trouble: lead, cadmium, arsenic and mercury.

This guide covers who has to comply, which chemicals matter, how daily exposure is calculated, what the warning must say, and how to stay out of a 60-day notice.

This article is for general education and isn’t legal advice. Talk to Prop 65 counsel about your specific products.

Who Has to Comply

Prop 65 applies to any business with 10 or more employees whose products reach consumers in California. Businesses with fewer than 10 employees are exempt, and so are government agencies.

A few points catch brands off guard:

  • You don’t need to be based in California. The law covers products sold there, including online orders shipped into the state.
  • Employee count is company-wide. The 10-employee threshold counts your whole company, not just staff in California.
  • Manufacturers carry most of the responsibility. The regulations put the primary duty to warn on manufacturers, distributors and importers. Retailers usually pass along the warnings you provide.
  • Small brands still feel the pressure. Even if you’re exempt, retailers and distributors often require Prop 65 compliance or indemnity in their vendor agreements.

The Four Heavy Metals That Matter Most

Lead, cadmium, arsenic and mercury occur naturally in soil and water, and plants absorb them as they grow. That makes them hard to avoid in botanicals, minerals, cocoa, rice and seafood. Lead is the biggest concern, with a safe harbor of just 0.5 micrograms per day.

OEHHA, the state agency that runs Prop 65, sets a “safe harbor” level for many listed chemicals, including three of these four metals. Exposure below that level needs no warning. There are two kinds:

  • NSRL (No Significant Risk Level) applies to chemicals listed for cancer.
  • MADL (Maximum Allowable Dose Level) applies to chemicals listed for reproductive harm.
Heavy metalSafe harbor (µg/day, by mouth)Common sources
Lead0.5 (MADL); 15 (NSRL)Botanicals, cocoa, spices, minerals like calcium, protein powders
Mercury (methylmercury)None adopted (settlements commonly use 0.3)Fish, seafood, some supplements and traditional remedies
Inorganic arsenic10 (NSRL)Rice, seaweed, some herbal ingredients
Cadmium4.1 (MADL)Cocoa, leafy greens, seaweed, some botanicals

When a metal has both levels, the lower one is usually the one that matters. For lead, that’s the 0.5 µg/day MADL. Mercury has no official safe harbor level, so there’s no regulatory number that clearly keeps you out of trouble. In practice, many Prop 65 settlements set 0.3 µg/day as the point where a warning is required.

Safe harbor values come from OEHHA’s published NSRL and MADL list. Check the current list before relying on a number, since values can change.

How Daily Exposure Is Calculated

A warning depends on daily exposure, not concentration alone. A product with a tiny amount of lead can still need a warning if people eat a lot of it every day.

Most enforcers and many settlements use the serving size and servings per day on your label:

Daily exposure (µg/day) = concentration (µg/g) × serving size (g) × servings per day

Lab results usually come in parts per million (ppm). For solids, 1 ppm equals 1 µg per gram, so you can use the ppm number directly.

Prop 65 daily exposure formula: concentration times serving size times servings per day, with a protein powder example at 1.2 micrograms of lead per day versus the 0.5 microgram safe harbor

Worked Example: A Protein Powder

  • Lab result: 0.04 ppm lead (0.04 µg/g)
  • Serving size: 30 g
  • Label directions: 1 serving per day
  • Daily exposure: 0.04 × 30 × 1 = 1.2 µg/day

That’s well over lead’s 0.5 µg/day MADL, so this product would need a warning. If the directions said 2 servings per day, exposure would double to 2.4 µg/day.

Two Factors That Can Lower Your Number

  • Average consumption. The regulations base exposure on the average consumer, not the maximum label serving every day. Food companies have won recent cases using average consumption data instead of the enforcer’s every-day calculation.
  • Naturally occurring chemicals. Under 27 CCR § 25501, a chemical that occurs naturally in a food doesn’t count as an “exposure” to the extent you can prove it. The burden of proof is on you, and it’s hard to meet without solid data.

Both defenses take evidence and usually legal help. Most brands plan around the label-based calculation and treat these as backups.

What the Warning Must Say

Food and supplements use their own “safe harbor” warning wording, set out in 27 CCR § 25607.2. Using that exact wording is the surest way to be treated as compliant.

Long-Form Warning

For lead, which is listed for both cancer and reproductive harm, the full-length warning reads:

WARNING: Consuming this product can expose you to chemicals including lead, which is known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. For more information go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov/food.

OEHHA publishes sample warnings for each case: cancer only, reproductive harm only, or both.

Short-Form Warning

Since January 1, 2025, food labels can use a short-form warning. The new short form names at least one chemical. Examples:

  • WARNING: Cancer risk from exposure to [chemical]. See www.P65Warnings.ca.gov/food.
  • WARNING: Risk of reproductive harm from exposure to [chemical]. See www.P65Warnings.ca.gov/food.
  • WARNING: Risk of cancer from exposure to [chemical] and reproductive harm from exposure to [chemical]. See www.P65Warnings.ca.gov/food.

Products manufactured and labeled before January 1, 2028, may keep the older short form with no chemical named. Anything made on or after that date needs the new wording.

Formatting Rules for Food Labels

Sample Prop 65 long-form and short-form food warnings for lead, with label formatting rules

How Prop 65 Is Enforced

Most Prop 65 cases are brought by private enforcers, not the state, and they start with a 60-day notice. Penalties can reach $2,500 per violation per day.

Prop 65 enforcement timeline: testing, 60-day notice, 60-day waiting period, then settlement or trial, with penalties up to $2,500 per violation per day

The usual sequence:

  1. Testing. An enforcer buys your product, often online, and has it tested for lead or other listed chemicals.
  2. 60-day notice. They send a notice of violation to your company and to public prosecutors, including the California Attorney General. The notice is posted publicly on the Attorney General’s website.
  3. Waiting period. If no public prosecutor takes up the case within 60 days, the private enforcer can file suit.
  4. Settlement or trial. Most cases settle. Settlements typically include a payment, the enforcer’s attorneys’ fees, and a commitment to warn or reformulate.

The enforcer doesn’t have to show anyone was harmed, only that an exposure above the safe harbor level happened without a warning. That’s why a single lab result can turn into a costly claim.

A Practical Prop 65 Compliance Plan

The goal is to know your daily exposure numbers before an enforcer does. Five steps get you there:

  1. Test finished products. Use an accredited lab and test the finished product, not just raw ingredients. Test enough lots to see how much results vary.
  2. Collect supplier data. Ask for heavy metal results on every certificate of analysis (COA), especially for botanicals, minerals, cocoa and protein sources.
  3. Calculate exposure from your label. Multiply each result by your serving size and the maximum servings per day on your directions. Compare it with the safe harbor levels.
  4. Decide: reformulate, warn, or document. If you’re over a limit, you can change ingredients or suppliers, adjust serving directions, or add a compliant warning. If you’re under, keep the math on file.
  5. Re-check whenever something changes. A new supplier, a reformulation or a new serving size changes your numbers. Retest at least once a year.

Keep records of all of it: lab reports, COAs, calculations and the reasoning behind your decision. If a 60-day notice arrives, that file is your first line of defense.

What Else Brands Should Know About Prop 65

Supplements Follow the Food Rules

Dietary supplements use the same food warning wording and the same /food web address. They often face more scrutiny, though, because botanicals and minerals tend to carry more lead.

Blanket Warnings Have Costs

Adding a warning to every product “just to be safe” can scare off shoppers and retailers. A warning also has to be accurate, so it should name a chemical that’s actually present. Most brands warn only where their numbers call for it.

A Warning Doesn’t Mean a Product Is Unsafe

The safe harbor levels are set well below the levels shown to cause harm. A warning means exposure is above California’s threshold, not that the product breaks federal food safety rules.

Online-Only Brands Are Covered Too

If you have 10 or more employees and ship to California customers, Prop 65 applies even if you only sell online. The warning has to appear on the product page or be shown before purchase, as well as on the package.

Where the Warning Goes on Your Label

The regulations don’t fix one spot, but the warning has to be easy to see before purchase. Many brands put it on the back panel near the Nutrition or Supplement Facts panel, in a box, at a legible size.

Conclusion

Prop 65 comes down to one number: daily exposure, compared with a safe harbor level. Know your test results, your serving size and your daily directions, and you’ll know whether you need a warning before anyone else tells you.

Your label and your Prop 65 math depend on the same data. The serving size and directions on your Nutrition or Supplement Facts panel set your exposure, so a change to one should trigger a fresh look at the other.

Panelgea helps food and supplement brands build FDA-compliant Nutrition and Supplement Facts panels from their own formulation data, with serving sizes and declarations kept in one place. Get started with Panelgea to keep your labels accurate as your formulas change.

Sources

FAQ

Panelgea® is REJIMUS, INC.’s platform for generating compliant, print-ready Nutrition and Supplement Facts panels. It runs built-in compliance and conflict checks as you build your panel, so formatting, rounding, and declaration errors get caught before your file ever reaches a designer.

 

Yes, the platform supports the full range of FDA-permitted formats, and the panel configuration step lets you set the product and package parameters that determine which formats are available to you.

 

Both workflows are supported. You can build a panel ingredient-by-ingredient using Panelgea’s integrated USDA ingredient database, or enter values directly from a certificate of analysis if you already have lab-tested nutritional data.

 

Panelgea exports panels as JPG, PNG, PDF, and editable SVG – the SVG format is print-ready and can be handed directly to a designer or dropped straight into label artwork without redrawing.

 

Yes, the free plan allows up to 10 panels per month, which is enough to test the workflow on a real product before deciding on a Professional or Enterprise subscription.

 

With Panelgea, we’ve set out to change the industry standard, not just in the way compliance is managed but in how businesses can access and use it. Whether you’re a small startup or an established company, Panelgea puts compliance in your hands—without the exorbitant price tag.

Join us in ensuring safety, efficiency, and accessibility in the compliance world.